A Legal Shot

Can a company maintain and build market share by aggressively suing its rivals? Consider the David vs. Goliath legal battle between Birmingham's On Go Energy drink and Farmington Hills's 5-Hour Energy drink.


(page 1 of 7)

Derrick George was about to pitch his new energy drink to a group of national distributors at a trade show in Chicago when his office called. They said the FBI was at the back door of his business, Aspen Fitness Products in Birmingham, with a search warrant.

The agents, who arrived in three unmarked white vans, proceeded to seize and haul away several boxes of company records. They also interrogated Aspen’s staff, including a new crop of interns, about whether George was a chemist and whether he was a manufacturer, along with other pertinent questions. “All the interns knew was that I was a lawyer, and they pointed to my diploma on the wall,” George says of the May 2009 incident.

“I can’t say for sure who said what to have the FBI search my offices, but my biggest competitor (5-Hour Energy) was across the aisle from me at the trade show. And just as I’m about to present my energy drink to the distributors, the FBI is banging on my door at my office in Birmingham. The timing was rather suspicious.”

It wasn’t until March 2011 that the FBI returned Aspen’s records, sources say. Gina Balaya, public information officer for the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Detroit, says she can neither confirm nor deny that a raid took place. “No charges have been filed against Mr. George or Aspen Fitness Products,” she says.

Soon after the search, George says he heard from various channels who said they were concerned Aspen was under investigation by the FBI. “You can bet I didn’t tell any of my suppliers or contacts the FBI had raided my offices, but someone was out there spreading the news to my network,” George says. “And I’m sure it wasn’t the FBI. They don’t talk to anyone.”

It wasn’t long after the FBI returned his company records that Innovation Ventures in Farmington Hills, which produces, distributes, and sells the popular 5-Hour Energy drink, sued George and Aspen Fitness Products in U.S. District Court. The complaint, which revived similar allegations from a lawsuit in Oakland County Circuit Court that was dismissed in May 2009, claimed Aspen obtained stolen “trade secret formulas” and customer or vendor lists via a former 5-Hour Energy executive. The case is now in discovery.

Edit Module
Edit Module Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Related Articles

30 in Their Thirties 2015

The 2015 class of 30 in Their Thirties offers products and services from Michigan that span the world, from the latest fashions to data enterprises to wholesale mortgage lending to luxury shopping malls.

Next Generation

General Motors and Ford Motor Co. are investing millions of dollars to upgrade their historic technical and research centers in a bid to better compete for talent with Google, Apple, Uber, and others.

Mad Dog

Following 40 years at Compuware Corp., Peter Karmanos Jr. — with a group of 25 technologists — is out to revolutionize the $700-billion commercial automations systems industry.

Robbing Peter to Pay Paul

During the last two years of Peter Karmanos Jr.’s tenure as chairman of Compuware Corp., a Shakespearian-type drama unfolded that led the board to fire him and cancel more than $4.1 million in vested stock options.

Hyper Speed

The inside story of how a trio of young entrepreneurs convinced billionaire Dan Gilbert to back high-speed Internet service in Detroit — and beyond.
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Most Popular

  1. Downtown Detroit’s Historic Beaubien House Sold
    The historic Beaubien House in downtown Detroit, previously owned and occupied by the American...
  2. Robotic Butler Delivers Amenities to Guests at Detroit’s Aloft Hotel
    A robotic butler named Botlr — capable of assisting hotel staff in delivering amenities from...
  3. Guest Blog: 6 Tips for a Longer Business Life in the Digital Era
    A new fact of life in the Digital Era is that the survival span of businesses seems to be...
  4. Lawn Care App Adds On-Demand Snow Removal Services in Metro Detroit
    Wixom-based LawnGuru, an app launched last May that offers on-demand lawn care for metro Detroit...
  5. 5Qs: Art Van Elslander on Saving Detroit's Thanksgiving Day Parade
    The Thanksgiving Day Parade in downtown Detroit on Thursday marks 25 years since Art Van...
  6. Motorsports Team Buhl Sport Detroit to Open HQ in Corktown
    Buhl Sport Detroit, a racing team and motorsports marketing group owned by brothers Robbie and...