Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print Feed Feed

Employee accountability vs. Employee entitlement

Baseball umpires and public school teachers, what could they possibly have in common?


Both groups of unionized employees have come under public attack for their lack of employee evaluation methods, each group preferring to go with longevity and tenure, over competency testing and management evaluations. On May 29th, Jim Leyland, the manager of the Detroit Tigers, went on one of his infamous rants regarding the poor performance of umpires in a game against the Cleveland Indians. In the 2010 documentary, Waiting For Superman, Michelle Rhee, then the chancellor of the Washington, D.C. public schools from 2007 to 2010, was featured in the documentary about the failing public school system, begging to have teachers evaluated and compensated on the merits of their performance. Both Leyland and Rhee made a public call for accountability and employee evaluations for groups of employees who are not evaluated.


Both groups of employees, through their respective union representation, have publically stated they will not stand for such practices. Instead, they will stand by their mantra of longevity and experience which they believe is more valuable to employers than actually measuring competency and performance. This is an outdated, antiquated thought process that does not foster a healthy working environment. Specifically regarding the education of our children, it is purely selfish on the part of the teachers who put their own needs of job security ahead of the needs of the students they teach. In an article published in USA Today (12/7/12), out of 34 countries, the U.S. ranked 14th in reading, 17th in science, and 25th in math. Some would argue that the umpires are doing a better job.


In the private sector (aka The Real World), business owners could not even think of adopting this type of employee management practice. It’s too laborious and doesn’t reward the top performers; rather it protects the underperformers and causes division amongst employee ranks. Top performers know they are good at their jobs and are able to earn a wage that rewards their superiority. Top performing employees also know which of their co-workers underperform, or does the bare minimum of work.  By rewarding every employee equally, or on seniority, the top performers are no longer incentivized to continue their superior performance because there isn’t any possibility to earn a higher wage or a promotion.   


I am not pro-union or anti-union. What I am is Pro-Accountability and Pro-Pay for Performance as it regards employee efforts in the workplace. As the American workforce morphs and evolves, employers in most sectors need to locate the best talent, eliminate underperformers, and create an employee culture that breeds harmony and cohesion.


Comments are moderated for appropriate language.

Add your comment:

Contact: Email

About Employment

Todd Palmer
Diversified Industrial Staffing and Diversified PEOple, LLC

Todd Palmer is founder and president of Troy-based Diversified Industrial Staffing and Diversified PEOple, LLC. Since 1997, Palmer's companies have helped over 4,300 people secure employment — improving their lives and the lives of their families. In turn, his companies have collectively billed more than $50 million in revenue.

From 2007-2013, INC Magazine named Diversified Industrial Staffing to its INC 5,000 list of the fastest growing companies in America. In 2011, Diversified Industrial Staffing was named a Michigan 50 Company to Watch. In 2009, Palmer published his first book, The Job Search Process, which helps people get new jobs in as little as seven days.

His company has been featured in INC Magazine, The Detroit News, DBusiness Magazine, Crain's Detroit Business, and MetroMode. Palmer has been on the radio with the Business Reality Network and the Dan Mulhern Show, and was featured on Entreprenuer Television in a 30-minute sit-down interview.

Palmer is a graduate of Eastern Michigan University with a bachelor's degree in Organizational Communication and minor in Marketing.

Recent posts

Archive »
The Downsides of Increasing Minimum Wage Keeping an Eye on the Labor Participation Rate How Employers Can Avoid a Bad Hire Every Business Leader Should Do a Triathlon — At Least Once Potential Job Turnover Crisis Looming Firing Can be Good for the Company and Employee Vocational Education Viable Alternative for State's Workforce The Battle for Talented Employees to Get Worse Manufacturers Among Leaders of Job Creation in 2013 Finding Dream Job Takes Effort, Commitment

This site is a member of the City & Regional Magazine Association Online Network